Everything Bagels Toppings: A Guide to Delicious Variations

For many of us, the combination of a freshly baked everything bagel and our favorite topping is one of life’s greatest pleasures. Not only do they taste delicious, but the range of toppings you can put on your bagel is almost endless! In this guide, we will explore some classic and unique ideas for what to put on your everything bagel, as well as how to make your own homemade toppings at home. So let’s get started exploring all the delicious possibilities that come with creating the perfect everything bagel.

everything bagels toppings

Classic Everything Bagel Toppings

The classics are always popular, and it’s easy to see why when it comes to everything bagels. Some tried and true combinations include cream cheese or butter topped with smoked salmon and red onion, as well as plain cream cheese with tomato slices. These combos have stood the test of time, and for good reason! They provide a delicious balance of savory and creamy flavors that combine perfectly.

Unique Everything Bagel Toppings

Sometimes you just want something a little different from the usual options. If that’s the case, there are plenty of more creative options out there! Consider topping your bagel with hummus and diced cucumber, nut butter and banana slices, Greek yogurt mixed with chopped fresh herbs, or ricotta cheese mixed with fig jam. There’s no limit to what you can create with a bit of creativity.

Sweet Everything Bagel Toppings

Who said bagels had to be savory? If you’re in the mood for something sweet, you can still enjoy an everything bagel! Top it off with peanut butter and sliced strawberries, almond butter and honey, cream cheese and blueberry jam, or Greek yogurt and granola for a satisfying treat. You could also try spreading cream cheese and sprinkling cinnamon sugar over top for a unique twist.

Healthy Everything Bagel Toppings

If you’re looking for something healthier, never fear – there are plenty of options here too! Instead of cream cheese or butter, consider using mashed avocado as your base. Then add protein-packed toppings like hard boiled eggs, tuna salad, smoked trout, or cooked shrimp. You can also use vegetables like sprouts or arugula for extra crunch and flavor. Don’t forget about healthy fats like olive tapenade or olives either – they go great with most everything bagels!

Making Your Own Everything Bagel Toppings at Home

Making your own everything bagel toppings at home is easier than you might think! Start by mixing together your favorite ingredients such as soft cheeses, fresh herbs, nuts, seeds, fruits, and vegetables. From there you can get creative with seasonings like garlic powder, chili flakes, paprika, cumin, turmeric, or anything else you like. The possibilities are truly endless! Once you have made your mixture, spread it onto the bagel before baking or store it in the fridge for up to a week so you can enjoy it any time.

Adding Extra Flavor to Your Everything Bagel Toppings

There are plenty of ways to give your bagel topping extra flavor without adding unhealthy ingredients. Try adding herbs and spices like chives, dill, rosemary, thyme, parsley, basil, oregano, garlic powder, pepper, sea salt, or chili flakes. This is a great way to liven up otherwise boring combinations like plain cream cheese or butter. You can also drizzle olive oil over the top of your finished bagel if desired – it adds another layer of flavor without much effort.

Including Protein in Your Everything Bagel Topping Combination

If you’re looking for an extra boost of energy from your bagel meal, consider including some protein in your topping combination. Chopped chicken breast makes a great addition to a traditional cream cheese topping, while canned tuna or shredded rotisserie chicken both work wonderfully with mayonnaise based spreads. For vegan and vegetarian eaters alike, try adding tofu cubes or chickpeas for added texture and nutrition.

Vegan and Vegetarian Everything Bagel Topping Ideas

Vegan and vegetarian everything bagels don’t need to miss out on deliciousness! Options like vegan cream cheese (made from cashews) mixed with spinach leaves and artichoke hearts make a tasty combo. Hummus topped with sliced tomatoes and roasted bell peppers is another winner. Avocado mash mixed with black beans and salsa provides a Southwestern flare that everyone can enjoy. And lastly, a smear of tahini paired with pickled onions and capers creates a delicious Mediterranean vibe that you won’t want to pass up!


As you can see, there are lots of delicious variations when it comes to creating the perfect everything bagel topping combination. Whether you’re looking for something classic or adventurous, sweet or savory, simple or complex – there’s an option for everyone! Plus, making your own toppings at home is fun and easy too. So the next time you’re in the mood for an everything bagel snack or meal, take some inspiration from this guide to discover new flavors and combinations that will tantalize your taste buds!

Leave a Comment